Lifesaving Poems: Brendan Kennelly’s ‘May the Silence Break’

photo (11)

May the Silence Break

Because you do not speak
I know the shock
of water encountering a rock.

Supremacy of silence is what I hate.
Only gods and graves have a right to that
or one who knows what this is all about.

Perhaps you do.
If so, let something break through
the walls of silence surrounding you.

Out here among words
your silence is the magnet I am drawn towards.
Men’s mouths, animals eyes and the throats of birds

fear this impenetrable thing.
So do I, all day long
and when the night drops like a confirmation

of what you are,
controller of every star,

of what the daylight struggled to reveal.
This possession kills
whatever it wills.

Nothing I say matters tonight.
Nor should it.
This silence is right

because it knows it is.
I shiver in the cocksure ice
and long for the warmth of bewildered eyes.

May the silence break
and melt into words that speak
of pain and heartache

and the hurt that is hard to bear
in the world out here
where love continues to fight with fear

and the war on silence will end in defeat
for every heart permitted to beat
in the air that hearts make sweet.

Brendan Kennelly, from A time for Voices

I called this series of posts Lifesaving Poems because I actually believe there is something redemptive and healing in the art of making, speaking, listening to and reading poems.

This may sound terribly old hat and beyond the pale, but I now feel I have lived long enough and seen enough things to have some kind of confidence, however tentative, in that claim. If you have read the posts in this series you will know how my own experience, especially of illness, has shaped my search for these transformative capabilities.

I have had special cause to reflect on this in the past week, having lost two friends who in their different ways also believed this to be true. At the funeral of one I chose to read another poem of Brendan Kennelly, ‘The Good’, which you can read here, in honour of this.

My first experience of seeing that working out in the life of someone else occurred in an encounter with another of his poems, ‘May the Silence Break’, below.

Several years ago we got the news that a young family friend had been involved in a road traffic accident. She had been hit by a car, which did not stop to attend to her. We found her in a hospital which specialised in head injuries. The doctors, in their frank way, said she would be affected for life by what had happened to her and while we could expect her to live she would need almost constant care.

The doctors encouraged us to speak to her, hearing being the most enduring of the senses. Would you mind if we read to her, we asked. They thought that was a good idea. Almost on a whim I took in Kennelly’s A Time for Voices (Bloodaxe, 1990) to read to her. Partly this was because it was what I was reading at the time, but I also sensed that Kennelly was someone who knew about ‘the war on silence’ and the cost of trying to overcome it.

Plus, I felt I had nothing else to lose.

Over the next two weeks I read the poems to her, after work, as she slept.

Watching her now you would not know what had happened to her. She is married with children;  she has a successful career. It is a miracle. Every time we speak I think back to those vigils by her bedside, watching the apparatus surrounding her help her breathe bleeping softly in the blue glow of the ward, praying for the silence to break.

Lifesaving Poems

If you liked this, why not try John Burnside’s ‘A Private Life’ or Tom Paulin’s ‘A Lyric Afterwards’


  1. What a beautiful poem, thank you for sharing.

    I think poetry touches us in a way that other words spoken or written cannot. When my father in law died 6 years ago, we all sat at the funeral service listening to his life enfold in words but it was only when my, then 10 year old, daughter stood up to read a poem she had written that anyone was really effected. She captured the essence of him beautifully, much more so than any of his friends in their long rambling anecdotes could, by the time she had finished there wasn’t a dry eye in the house.


    1. Thank you so much for taking the time to comment on this post.
      Strangely enough I was at a funeral today, reading a poem in memory of the deceased.
      It was what everyone was talking about afterwards.
      Yours with very best wishes and thanks


  2. Anthony, there’s nothing “old hat” about your views on the value of poetry at all!
    Au contrare Monsieur! As a matter of fact, the Welsh-Irish poet, David Whyte, would endorse your views completely! Great blog you’ve got!


    1. Thank you so much for your encouragement, Rob.
      The more I think about poetry as a lifesaving force, the more I am persuaded I was right all along.
      No old hat indeed. So pleased you found the blog and do spread the word!
      With thanks and good wishes


  3. Poetry is my saviour. I lost my sister 3 months ago. Writing poetry and the reading of others, such as the profound exquisite piece above certainly comforts and guides me during this time of trauma and immense sadness.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.