Last week I gave up writing. For about a day. I had been given a book by one of my literary heroes, a poet I have admired from afar without ever meeting. The minute I opened it I had two reactions. The first was one of intense joy (I did not know he had even brought out a new book) and pleasure to see him on as good as form as ever. This was quickly followed by intense realisation of the poverty of my own work, the narrowness of its vision and ambition now in sharp and plain relief thanks to the book I held in my hand. I put the book down and pledged never to write another word.
I think I have always had this feeling when coming face to face with greatness, an awed version of fight or flight, a kind of reverse-jealously, unconscious acknowledgement of what I have secretly known all along, that I should leave it to those who can do it better than me. Which is of course everyone. I used to get it in maths lessons, furtively looking round in the hope that someone would be struggling as much as me. Now I get it with poetry, most acutely in the workshop that I used to belong to. I can still remember the morning when Andy Brown bought in his poem Prayer/ Why I am Happy to be in the City This Spring and basically deciding right there and then to leave the group to it, even though it was meeting in my house. Here, in front of me, was the poem that I had been trying to write for years, brilliantly alive and realised, equal to its daring, including that of remaining simple. I loved it (love it) more than I can say, proof if it were needed that poetry can do anything. I had it with Catherine Smith’s How It All Started, actually standing up and applauding in my kitchen, the pages of The Rialto which contained it curling back over its miracle-gift in slow motion. I had it a year or two ago when Ann Gray showed me My Blue Hen, not because it had just won a massive prize, but because I knew in my bones I would never write anything as good. (I actually told Ann this. I think she thought I was joking.)
To make up for my self-loathing, I am fortunate that I get reverse-giving-up by the same token. Mostly I know I am in the presence of these encourager-mentors when I start going through notebooks (any paper in fact) as though certain I might have an appointment with the proverbial front wheels of the bus the following morning. Thinking doesn’t really come into it. It is as though the world of the poem and the world I am walking through, eating and working in have become the same. I remember feeling exactly that, exactly that feeling of how-does-he-know-so-much-about-my-life, reading Ilhan Berk in a campsite in Cornwall two years ago. It isn’t about wanting to become Ilhan Berk (or James Schuyler, or John Ash), let alone write like him. It’s about discerning a rhythm, a way of looking and listening, and wanting to join in the conversation, seeing where my answer will take me, then doing everything to get out of their way before I can persuade myself to give up, exhausted.
Ah, such an honest confession. And you probably are so much better than you give yourself credit for. I’ve seen this before with people who I know are way better than I am. Cheers to you and your pure heart, good poet.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Yes, I think we all go through moments like that, but we are not all as honest about it as you are. Thank you.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I guess this is very common indeed, even among the so-called greats.
That bit about the maths class brought me back nearly 50 years in less than 5 seconds!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Nailed it, Mr Wison. Like my singer/songwriter mate at a gig we were at. Andrew Hardin (Tom Russell’s guitarist for years) had just played a riff that involved astonishing chord shapes, and a run of harmonics thrown in the mix….and the full length of the neck. Then he did it again. That’s it, said my accomplished guitarist mate. You can trap my fingers in a door. Of course, I didn’t and he’s still playing, 10 years later..
LikeLiked by 3 people
I can most certainly empathize.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A large tumbler of whiskey will do wonders for you mood.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nice. Thank you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s lovely to appreciate the talents of others so fully! I certainly know the feelings you describe. Wishing you a blessed spring day, Anthony. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awesome work I love it!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, this is exactly how it is! The joy and the despair induced by reading a perfect poem.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So many of us in the trenches feel this way at so many moments on our writer’s journey. Thank you for this honesty and letting us *see* you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We, writers, can be such envious and self loathsome creatures, but the craving will never stop.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Absolutely love it, and am intimately acquainted with this thought wave. I have been looking for a site that deals with poetry and creative writing. I think I will follow you around, if that’s alright with you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for your kind words. By all means enjoy my blog. Thank you for your support, Anthony
LikeLike